Tree health
Signs a tree needs to be removed (and when it can stay)
Short answer
The clearest signs a tree needs to be removed are a dying canopy, deep cracks or splits in the trunk, a lean that’s new or getting worse, fungus or soft wood at the base, and roots lifting out of the soil. They matter most when the tree stands over a house, driveway, fence or play area. One sign alone doesn’t always mean removal, but two or more is a good reason to get the tree checked.

A 5-minute walk-around
Walk all the way around the tree and look up, then down. Note anything you find with a photo.
- Canopy: large dead branches, bare sections, or leaves much thinner than similar trees on your street.
- Trunk: deep vertical cracks, a split at a fork, cavities, or bark falling off in sheets.
- Lean: a lean that’s new, or soil cracking or heaving on the side opposite the lean.
- Base and roots: mushrooms or shelf fungus, soft or crumbly wood, roots cut by recent digging.
- Target: what’s underneath: the roof, bedrooms, cars, a fence, the sidewalk, a power line.
Start with what the tree could hit
A tree with a defect isn’t automatically dangerous. Risk is two things together: how likely part of the tree is to fail, and what it would land on. A dead tree at the back of a large Barber Valley lot is a very different situation from the same tree leaning over a bedroom in the North End.
Dead or dying canopy
In spring, compare your tree with similar ones nearby. Leaves that come in thin or yellow, branches that stay bare and dieback that starts at the top and works down are signs the tree is struggling.
A few dead branches can usually be pruned out. The concern grows when large sections of the crown are dead or the dieback keeps spreading year after year. Fully dead trees get more brittle the longer they stand, which makes them harder and riskier to take down later.
Cracks, splits and weak forks
Look at the trunk and where the big limbs join it. Deep cracks, a seam running down from a fork, or a split you can see light through are serious. Trees with two trunks of similar size growing from one point often form a tight V with bark trapped inside, and that’s a classic place to split in wind or wet snow.
A crack that appears suddenly after a storm needs prompt attention. A long-standing weak fork can sometimes be managed with structural pruning.

A new or worsening lean
A lean the tree has had for years is usually fine. A new one, especially with cracked or heaved soil on the far side, is not: keep people and cars out from under it and read is a leaning tree dangerous?
Fungus, decay and root damage
Mushrooms or shelf-like conks on the trunk or around the base usually mean decay inside. Other clues are cavities, soft wood, carpenter ants and a hollow sound when you tap the trunk. Trees can wall off decay, so what matters is how much sound wood is left.
Roots get damaged too. A sprinkler trench, new driveway, fence or addition can cut major roots, and the tree may not show it for a year or two.
Boise trees that tend to cause trouble
Silver maple, Siberian elm and cottonwood grow fast on weak wood, and many of the older ones in Boise are now large and heavy. Ornamental (Callery) pears tend to split at the fork. None of that means a tree has to go, but it’s worth a closer look when one of them is over the house. For ash, see the tree health checks page on emerald ash borer.
FAQ
Common questions
How can I tell if my tree is dying?
Look for thin or missing leaves compared with similar trees, dieback starting at the top, large dead branches, loose bark and fungus at the base. One sign on its own doesn’t always mean the tree is dying.
Do mushrooms at the base mean the tree must come down?
They often point to decay in the roots or lower trunk. Whether it needs removal depends on how much sound wood is left and what the tree could hit.