Skip to content

Open 24/7, every day, including emergencies

Boise, ID · (208) 504-3056

Stumps

Stump grinding vs stump removal: which do you need?

Short answer

The difference is depth. Grinding cuts the stump down a few inches below the surface and leaves the deeper roots to break down in place. Stump removal digs out the stump and its main root ball. Grinding suits most lawns and beds; removal is for when you need to dig, build or plant in that exact spot.

A ground-down stump area beside the hole left by full stump removal

Side by side

Stump grinding vs stump removal
Stump grindingStump removal
What happensStump ground into chips below the surfaceStump and main root ball dug out
DepthSeveral inches below grade, deeper on requestThe whole root ball
DisturbanceSmall; works close to fences and pavingLarger hole and more lawn damage
TimeUsually quick per stumpLonger, especially in tight yards
Relative costUsually lowerUsually higher
LeftoverWood chips; deep roots rot slowlyBackfilled hole; little wood left
Best forLawn, beds, mulch, mowing hazardsSlabs, footings, posts, replanting in the same spot

What stump grinding does

A stump grinder uses a spinning cutting wheel to chew the stump into chips, down to several inches below ground. The visible stump disappears and the area can be filled with soil and seeded or planted. The roots below are left to decay slowly. Grinding is less disruptive, works close to fences, patios and driveways, and is usually the quicker and more affordable option. See our stump grinding service.

Old tree stump left in a lawn next to a fence

What stump removal involves

Full removal digs out the stump and a large share of the main roots. It means more excavation, a bigger hole to backfill and more disturbance to the lawn. It’s the right choice when the ground needs to be clear deeper down: before a slab, fence posts or footings, new irrigation or utility lines, or a new tree in exactly the same spot. See stump removal.

Which one should you choose?

  • New lawn, sod, mulch or a flower bed: grinding.
  • Stump close to a foundation, sidewalk or neighbor’s fence: grinding.
  • Patio, shed, slab or addition on the spot: removal.
  • Fence posts or footings right there: removal, or move the post a little and grind.
  • New tree in the same hole: removal, or plant a few feet away and grind.
  • Stump keeps sprouting: grind deeper first; removal if it persists.

Sprouting, settling and the chips

Cottonwood, poplar, willow, Siberian elm and some maples can send up shoots from leftover roots. Grinding deeper and cutting new shoots back for a season usually ends it.

Grinding produces a mound of chips mixed with soil. Keep some as mulch, but grass grows poorly in chips, so for lawn replace them with topsoil. Expect a little settling as the old wood decays and top up the spot later.

Before any stump work

Either way, call 811 at least two business days ahead, and flag your own sprinkler and lighting lines, since 811 only marks the utilities.

FAQ

Common questions

Can I grind now and dig the stump out later?

Yes. Grinding first is common, and the leftover roots and chips can be dug out later if plans change. Doing it twice costs more than doing removal once, so if a patio or fence is already planned for that spot, go straight to removal.

Which option leaves less mess?

Grinding. You get a pile of chips and a shallow patch to rake out. Removal leaves a hole that has to be backfilled, and the soil settles for a few months.

Can I plant a new tree where the old stump was?

Yes, but it’s easier to plant a short distance away, or to remove the stump and chips fully and replace them with good soil first.

Is stump removal more expensive than grinding?

Usually, because it involves more digging, hauling and backfill.

Talk to us

Got a stump to deal with?

Send a photo with something for scale and tell us what’s going in that spot next.

Call (208) 504-3056